GamesWrite
HomeGamesReviewsSearch
GamesWrite© 2026
HomeReviewsSearch

Gaming content & community platform. Built with passion for gamers.

PohnDip
PohnDip🧙'Murica✓
Nov 7

Hogwarts Legacy (Switch 2)

Overall
7.5out of 10
Great
Woke
0.3out of 10
Not Woke
Gameplay:7.7/10
Story:7.6/10
Graphics:8.6/10
Audio:8.4/10
Replayability:6.8/10
Scoring Weights: RPG GamesScoring Weights for RPG GamesScoreWeight% of TotalGameplay7.7220%Story7.6440%Graphics8.61.515%Audio8.41.515%Replayability6.8110%Weighted Avg: 78.1 ÷ 10 = 7.81Wokeness Penalty:Score (0.3) × Weight (-1) = -0.3Final Score (rounded to nearest 0.5):7.81 (avg) − 0.3 (penalty) = 7.51 → 7.5
Wokeness: -1Gameplay: 20%Story: 40%Graphics: 15%Audio: 15%Replayability: 10%
Hogwarts LegacyXbox Series X|SPlayStation 4Single PlayerRole-playing (RPG)Adventure

Playing Hogwarts Legacy during Halloween was almost unfair. The castle in autumn colors, Hogsmeade decorated for the season, the grounds covered in orange and gold. I walked through those halls for the first time in October, and the game met me exactly where I was. On the Switch 2, this is a Wizarding World adventure worth taking. It's also a game that peaks early and spends the back half coasting on the goodwill its world builds in those opening hours.

Hogwarts in autumn, seen from across the lake.

Woke: 0.3

The cast is noticeably more diverse than the films. A school that recruits the best young witches and wizards from around the world gives that some narrative cover, but it's still visible. There is one transgender character, Sirona Ryan, who runs the Three Broomsticks Tavern. It's acknowledged briefly in dialogue and left alone. Nothing is preached. Nothing is pushed on the player. The game is focused on being a Wizarding World adventure, and these elements exist in the background without driving the experience.

Hogsmeade decorated for Halloween.

Gameplay: 7.7

Early combat is simple and satisfying. You learn a handful of spells, enemies go down clean, and the loop feels good. That changes once you're carrying a full loadout and facing groups of enemies with different colored shields that each require a specific spell type to break. Cycling through spell sets mid-fight while trying to match colors gets clumsy, and the window to cancel out of a spell animation into a block or dodge is tight. Sometimes enemies hit you with no on-screen warning at all. Back yourself into a corner and the camera pulls in close enough to make the fight unreadable. Control spells were the highlight: Levioso to lift, Accio to pull snipers in close, Glacius to freeze, then Bombarda to finish. Stealth takedowns were a go-to for clearing camps. Damage spells felt weak on their own, and fights drifted toward a lot of basic attacks to finish enemies off.

A dragon passes overhead at sunset.

Broom flying was one of the best parts of the game. You click the left stick to cruise and just steer up, down, left, and right. No need to hold forward to keep speed. The hippogriff requires holding forward, so I preferred the broom every time. Early on I deliberately flew or ran between missions instead of fast traveling, just to take in the world. Seeing the castle and the highlands from above was a reward in itself.

Night flight on the broom, headed toward Feldcroft.

Some of the dungeons and puzzles kept things interesting too. One Keeper trial is presented as a black-and-white storybook with Deathly Hallows imagery, and it's one of the most creative sequences in the game. The talent system supported a clear build identity, but gear was disappointing. There are upgrade slots and additional modifiers you can add, but none of it felt like it made a real difference. Every piece felt like it just changed offense and defense numbers. I was drowning in loot that all felt the same. A deeper progression system with distinct build paths, something like a true beast trainer class with choices that actually matter, would have given the gameplay real legs.

Wand streams collide in the duel with Rookwood.

Story: 7.6

The main plot went somewhere I didn't expect. I thought the game would be about ancient magic itself, learning to master it, pushing its limits. Instead, it's about the Keepers and the secret they guard. That's a fine story, and it kept me invested to the end, but I wanted more from the ancient magic side. I wanted the Keepers to actually teach my character, to give me new abilities and deepen that connection. Professor Fig is one of the strongest characters in the game, and I wished he served more as a mentor than a companion who mostly tags along. Professor Weasley is excellent. Headmaster Black is entertaining with his snarky attitude, though he stays on the sidelines.

Ancient magic unleashed against a Pensieve Guardian.

Sebastian, Natty, and Poppy are supposed to be your closest friends, but only Sebastian stays woven into the main narrative through the dueling club and key story missions. His questline is the most intriguing thread in the game. Natty and Poppy live almost entirely in optional side quests, and that lack of presence makes their friendships feel hollow. More class time together, more main-story missions with all three, would have made those bonds land. Choices didn't feel like they carried much weight beyond how you build your character. The early game builds the world beautifully through school life: you meet people, attend classes, and each professor gives you a short real lesson. That fades. Later, classes only show up when you need a new spell, and the game shifts from world-building to a main quest and companion quest checklist.

I walked through those halls for the first time in October, and the game met me exactly where I was.

Visuals: 8.6

The Switch 2 handles this game well. I played mostly docked with some handheld sessions, and performance felt great for an open-world title of this size. Running through the grounds and pulling out the broom to fly was seamless. Hogwarts is massive and packed with detail from the books and films. The first trip to Hogsmeade was a standout, the kind of moment that makes you slow down and look at everything. The seasonal changes add another layer: autumn leaves blanketing the courtyards, Halloween decorations throughout the castle and Hogsmeade, then snow and Christmas lights in winter. I took more screenshots of the scenery than I did of combat.

Christmas decorations inside the castle.

There are occasional short pauses before some castle doors open, which looks like hidden loading, and the game crashed a handful of times in both docked and handheld. Neither was frequent enough to sour the experience, but they're worth noting. The settings menu deserves a mention too, with a large number of options to dial things in.

Audio: 8.4

The score captures the tone of the Wizarding World, and I never once muted it or put on something else. The game's sound stayed on the entire playthrough, which says a lot about how well the music fits. Voice acting is good across the board with no weak performances standing out. Professor Weasley and Professor Fig are the highlights, both delivering performances that give their characters real weight. Headmaster Black's snarky delivery is fun every time he shows up. I liked the settings options here too: you can switch the audio output profile between a soundbar when docked and headphones in handheld, which was a nice touch.

Replayability: 6.8

I'd come back to this game. The seasonal changes alone are worth revisiting, and the companion stories and post-game House Cup give me reasons to return. A fresh start is a harder sell, though. The side content is the problem. Merlin Trials are repeated filler tasks with a modest payoff. Map-clearing activities feel like checking boxes rather than giving you a reason to explore. The odd-job side quests are a mixed bag: diving into a lake to retrieve an item, clearing a spider den, recovering a merchant's wagons from a goblin camp. Some kept things interesting. The loot system that felt like it only changes numbers and the lack of distinct build paths mean a second playthrough would feel too similar to the first. More meaningful choices and a progression system that actually changed how you play would have made this a game I'd restart immediately.

Pros

  • Massive, faithful Hogwarts packed with book and movie details
  • Strong opening hours and a standout first trip to Hogsmeade
  • Halloween and Christmas seasonal decorations were a nice touch
  • Broom flying with cruise control is relaxing and rewarding
  • Control spells and stealth takedowns feel great
  • Solid voice cast led by Professors Fig and Weasley
  • Music that fits the Wizarding World
  • Reliable Switch 2 performance in docked and handheld

Cons

  • School life and class lessons fade after the opening
  • Combat gets clumsy with full loadouts and mixed shielded enemies
  • Tight block/dodge windows with occasional missing attack warnings
  • Gear and loot feel like they only change numbers
  • Natty and Poppy underused in the main story
  • Merlin Trials and map-clearing are repetitive filler
  • Choices carry little weight
  • Occasional crashes and brief door-loading pauses

Final Thoughts

Hogwarts Legacy gets the Wizarding World right in ways that matter. The castle is enormous, the grounds are gorgeous, and the first several hours of school life, exploration, and discovery are some of the most immersive world-building I've experienced in an action RPG. It earns that goodwill honestly. The problem is that the game spends the back half living off of it. The school life fades, the combat gets rougher as complexity outpaces the controls, and the side content leans too heavily on filler. Sebastian's storyline proves the writing team could deliver something compelling when they committed to it, which makes the underused companions and low-stakes choices sting more. On the Switch 2, it runs well, it looks great, and the seasonal atmosphere kept pulling me back in. If you're a fan of the Harry Potter books and you like games, I'd recommend it. If you're hoping for a game that matches the depth of its own world, you'll enjoy the stay but leave wanting more. What would Hogwarts Legacy look like with a progression system that actually let you become a different kind of wizard?

75

Comments (1)

nathanbunn20
nathanbunn20@nathanbunn20·Nov 10

100% agree. I stopped soon after those first few hours wore off and started to feel the repetition of the game loop. Without a progression system, or just something new to look forward to, it makes an open world of this size difficult to stay immersed in. Also the broom, which is amazing, kinda took something away from the game by no longer appreciating all the small details in the environment everywhere you went. Idk how they could fix that because the broom is such a good upgrade..

48